Last Hours Header Image

Notice! This is an archive version of Last Hours. It is no longer maintained or updated. Emails, addresses etc. may not be up to date.

Analysis of BBC discussion on direct action

November 18th, 2010 · post by Fred Goodsell · 1 Comment

Last night BBC radio 4 broadcast a discussion about the use of direct action in a ‘democratic’ society. You can listen to the show here.

Firstly it is worth noting that these types of discussions are usually very one sided. The student protests that smashed up the Tory HQ has caused a social shift where the theory of direct action, and indeed violence, has to be recognised and given some legitimacy by mainstream media. Up until this point the mainstream media has taken a hard-line stance against these sort of acts; now the discussion is back in the public domain. This can be put down to the larger public’s change in attitude and a recognition that current political and social institutions don’t represent us. What were once considered the only legitimate means of social change do not work and other means are required.

Many of the panel argued a moral stance either for or against direct action and violent protest. This in its self is a failure to recognize that key issues of political violence are not moral issue but that of power and privilege. Likening the bombing of an abortion clinic to class based political action ignores the flow of power behind these acts.

Using violence to gain authoritarian political, or social power, over a person, or group of people, can be considered, at least from an anti-authoritarian stance, as unjustified. However using violence as means to gain liberation is, and has been historically displayed as, critical to maintaining or gaining levels of freedom and bringing about the decentralisation of power.

Part of the reason that the panel are unable to recognize this is down to their own privilege. We can presume that all of the panel  have some general social privilege. With this presumption in mind, it is not unimaginable to think that the panel very rarely feel the oppressive nature of hierarchical social relationships. These positions of privilege also promote a vested interest in maintaining current social relationships that many of us recognize as repressive.

Of course violence takes place every single day and much of it is either accepted or viewed as justified. This violence almost always flows from positions of power onto those with less power. This may be war, police violence or domestic abuse as well as less obvious violence within general social hierarchies such as wage labour, patriarchy, racism etc.

Despite this the fact this argument is taking place should be considered an early success of the student protests as well as a sign public opinion is behind a struggle for a more egalitarian society. This struggle, of course, is not inherently violent but respects the individual or community choice to use the tactics they feel are required to maintain or gain the levels of freedom and equality they desire.

Further reading

Peter Gelderloos -  MP3 of public talk and following interview with the author of ‘How Non-Violence Protects the State’.

Pacifism as Pathology – Ward Churchill

Uri Gordon - Anarchy Alive! (Ch.4 – Peace, Love and Petrol Bombs: Anarchism and Violence Revisited)

→ 1 CommentThis entry belongs to the following categories: Blogs · Last Hours blog

1 response so far

  • kathy burnham posted:
    Jan 12, 2011 at 6:31 pm. Comment #1

    i didn’t hear the bbc broadcast unfortunately. there used to be an organization in east london called london action resource center which as i understand it acted as a kind of clearinghouse/umbrella group for direct action groups. i really do hope its still around as i was hoping to do some volunteer work there sometime soon. groups like this are great- kind of remind me of my campus activist days in the eighties.

about

Last Hours butterfliesName: Last Hours blog
Bio: Keep up to date with info relating to Last Hours, UK and international anti-authoritarian scenes. We will post news on new publications here was well as note worthy event and other such content
Web: www.archive.lasthours.org.uk

blog roll

  • Blue lights and sirens
  • Cookery corner
  • Hey Monkey Riot
  • Last Hours blog
  • Prancer
  • recent blog posts for Last Hours blog:


    latest blog posts

    1. New website and blog

      by Edd on 04 Aug

    2. M26 commentary

      by anon on 13 Apr

    3. Mayday! Mayday!

      by anon on 11 Apr

    4. Vegan cheese and onion pasties

      by xhannahx on 27 Mar

    5. Updates from the street on Saturday

      by Fred Goodsell on 24 Mar

    6. Some icons for the Symposium

      by Edd on 07 Mar

    last hours features